Dyneema vs nylon tent vs polyester tent reddit. It is also less forgiving of rough treatment.

Dyneema vs nylon tent vs polyester tent reddit Like nylon, polyester tents are a much cheaper option than tents made from other materials, so it is also a great budget option to consider when buying a tent. pick two: cheap, light, durable. For a tent, 30d is more than enough, so probably don't go any higher unless you're planning on thoroughly abusing it. Posted by u/GiveAlexAUsername - 7 votes and 5 comments Dec 2, 2022 · Is Dyneema or nylon better for tents? Dyneema is better for tents compared to nylon. I've used paracord and had no problems though. Undebatable that a DCF floor is significantly more expensive than nylon floor. The Sierra is a polyester tent, and the Eureka is a nylon tent with a polyester rainfly, so from a UV perspective they're both the same. Each has it`s advantages and disadvantages. 2oz/yd or 1oz per shelter heavier, but with a lifespan at least double (ask MLD who offer their shelters in both). IMO, things like the PU coating on the floor, zippers, inner netting, etc will all fail before you hit the crossover point where UV degradation becomes a factor in polyester vs nylon even in a tent used for car camping and left up all wekend. The roll I had was indisputably faulty. The nylon would stretch quickly under the tents tension forces and the dyneema would take all the load. Specific gravity of nylon is 1. Real world differences compared to nylon/polyester. It is also less forgiving of rough treatment. It's a lighter material. Pro-con: It's very light (~115g iirc). This superiority in tear strength makes a significant difference when you’re weighing options between Silnylon vs DCF (Dyneema Composite Fabric) tents. , this Atwood vs. Unless you're planning on leaving a tent set up someplace year-round, UV resistance of the fabric is not usually the limiting factor to its lifespan. The typical form factor is in a crazy light fabric for a tarp or tent where it is waterproof, and really hard to tear, which allows it to be lighter than a comparable nylon or polyester tarp. Nylon NatureHike also has a 20D sinNylon version of the CloudUP that is 8 or so oz lighter. Lineloc 3's require somewhere around a 2mm line and minis require about 1. Personally I like Dyneema webbing for load bearing purposes but it is $$$ and available in limited widths so you can’t use it with all components. 2 micro cord and been ok, but at that point, prusik/taught lines work better Ideally cord can hold knots, and dyneema is too stiff and slick to do so effectively. 20D nylon is more expensive to make but is a bit lighter. As in all aspects of tent design, fabric selection is a balancing act. 7) weight difference from 20D Nylon to 210T Polyester for the same tent! I would go for the 210T polyester tent if price and durability is a concern and the 20D nylon version if you want the lightest possible tent. So now I have a Rainbow Li. polyester/nylon paracord (e. The exception is dyneema or HDPE laminated fabric tents, which is a great fabric but it is very pricey, in a category all its' own and the topic of another article. Sep 16, 2023 · Nylon Tents. Sep 9, 2023 · 09:44 Dyneema Tents 10:29 Canvas vs Nylon Tents 11:26 Canvas vs Polyester Tents 12:31 Nylon vs Polyester Tents 13:34 Recommendations. I learned years ago the airline personnel always roll their clothes when packing, and I discovered this hold true to me for tents, sleeping bags, and sleeping pads as well. Polyester is more naturally water resistant (hydrophobic) than nylon, which is hydrophilic. Nylon is the stronger material that can make a pretty tough tent at 15D, but the trade off is that it absorbs water and sags. Additionally, Dyneema does not absorb any moisture and is waterproof. Like nylon, polyester is also a synthetic material. The most common comparo is 1. Nylon is worst with polyester in between. If I could get a copper spur with a dyneema fly and carbon poles… that would be my ideal bikepacking tent. Is it the difference in quality, durability, materials yes. The only reason I’m in this never-ending tent hunt is because Tarptent is not available in Europe :( When I contemplate tent fabrics, Dyneema consistently distinguishes itself for its long-term durability. Plus you can enjoy seeing the stars at night. Membrane Silpoly is very easy to rip unfortunately. Not much of a comparison, is it? No way I'm spending that on a tent. Find the perfect material for your next trip! Jan 22, 2025 · What is the difference in Nylon and Polyester? These are both synthetic fabrics, and polyester does have some subtle advantages in UV performance but Nylon is ounce for ounce tougher. which material would you guys suggest, leaving price out of the equation? Do you have ideas for any other more durable or ligjter materials? I appreciate any help you can give me. tents are no different than anything else in this space. Used a nylon tent during most of that time and it did get a couple very minor floor holes (easily taped) during that time. When it comes to choosing between these two popular tent materials , several factors come into play, such as cost, strength, lightweight properties, and No real difference in durability/protection, but big difference in ease of use. Before you link me to other threads of nylon vs dyneema, please read the response I got from Dan's team below as this is not normal dyneema. Polyamide is nylon and often a bit lighter but I hear the UV resistance is considerably less. Polyester doesn't stretch. Nylon is the most common, but polyester or DCF are better choices for your ultralight tent. He bought this tent in the Spring of 2017 and has used it for around 150 nights. Enjoy car camping like a car With canvas tents, rolling is always more compact than folding. A saggy rain fly means less air movement in between the fly and tent body which will result in more condensation and dampness in the tent. Traditionally, polyester is best, but modern technology has done for things to change. At a time when 20-plus-pound base weights had been common, 15- and even 10-pound base weights suddenly became widely attainable. That saves you roughly 2lbs compared to carrying either tent, neither of which serves any purpose in the wildernesses you visit. But I don't know that I have ever seen the type of polyester advertised when buying fabric, probably because there hasn't been much demand for that information, it is always just listed as polyester. Best canvas tents are ones without a ground sheet which reduces weight, still heavy but not as heavy as it would be. DCF (Dyneema Composite Fabric) has since grown in popularity. On a recent trip to Iceland a partner had a 2p mid from hyperlight mountain gear with the internal net and floor insert. Analyzing the tensile strength of Dyneema and Silnylon tents reveals that, although DCF tents exhibit high tension that may stress zippers, Silnylon’s slight elasticity offers durability benefits by reducing zipper strain. I have done this with my two backpacking tents, and they are both over ten years old. The other tent is my friend Porter’s Mountain Laurel Designs Solomid XL made of 30 denier silnylon. . Mar 1, 2023 · DCF was the revolutionary backpacking fabric of the 2000s. I especially like the idea of a polyester fly, as it does not sag/stretch like a sil-nylon fly does when wet. ) And I would never consider using nylon again in that wet of an environment. Borrowing an innovative fabric from sailboat racing, hikers were suddenly able to cut their tent weight by 50 percent overnight. net) Dyneema is insanely strong so you can use tiny rope. It needs to be very carefully constructed and reinforced to be used as a tarp that will last. Mini caribineer on one side, small prusic on the other. Polyester has its fair share of pros and cons when it comes to tents, so let’s take a look at those. This article is intended to provide users a basic level of understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of the most common fabrics used in tent and tarp design. I want to create a durable long lasting tent floor for myog tent. The best camping tent material depends a lot on how you'll use it. Get a 6lb $100 Coleman dome tent with lots of room. Jun 27, 2022 · Polyester doesn't stretch if it becomes whet and can better deal with UV rays. So if people feel the tent is overpriced compared to competitors since it has a nylon floor, then they shouldn't purchase it. Both are coated to achieve real waterproofness, but when both get wet overnight due to precipitation or condensation, polyester will dry slightly faster. Jul 8, 2024 · Additionally, some nylon tents may not be as durable as polyester tents, so it is important to consider the conditions you will be camping in before deciding on a material. For tents there are 2 types of materials: polyester and nylon. 6). I wish they made a version that only uses silicone and uses the newer high tenacity polyester fibers (it's sort of like nylon with nylon 6 vs robic and 6. See full list on outlifeexpert. Oct 19, 2024 · Unlike SilNylon, a polyester tent doesn’t have the tension issues and sagging that a nylon-based fabric does, so you can set it up once and not worry about it. It doesn't do well with abrasion, but a tent doesn't really experience abrasion. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Considering that switching out nylon for DCF in pre-existing double wall tent designs can push the price close to $1000 Lol. Also it's cheaper but most likely less durable. When you’re comparing silnylon vs DCF, it’s important to take into account tear strength and tent durability. Say that I’m taking either tent brand-new on a 7-day trip where there might be bad weather and long-lasting rain. It comes with a 70D taffeta nylon floor that is hydrostatically rated to 3,000 mm, and a footprint for underneath to protect the tent floor. g. Feb 25, 2019 · Rather than serving as a buying guide, this article is intended to provide users a very basic level of understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of the most common fabrics used in tent and tarp design: nylon, polyester, and DCF (Dyneema Composite Fabric, formerly known as Cuben Fiber). Does 1200mm vs. In this camping gear review video we'll cover everything you need to know about popular ca We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. If people who don't know about the limits of dyneema start buying more expensive DCF tents because they like poly or nylon tents from that brand, they're going to be disappointed when they end up less durable. Apr 6, 2015 · Nylon is stronger for the respective weight as compared to polyester. Some don't fold and roll their dyneema. Denier isnt everything. The linked article mentions that nylon 6 and nylon 66 perform differently, I would expect the same of the different types of polyester. Although both materials are artificial polymers, they have several basic differences which are crucial. 14 and polyester is 1. This makes them the best choice for situations such as extending a belay device, replacing anchor webbing or attaching yourself to an anchor before abseiling. With Silpoly (or nylon) I can stuff my Tarp and Bivy in my pack (no stuff sack) around other odd shaped objects, and it packs down significantly smaller. However, it tends to sag when wet and isn't as UV-resistant as other materials. Effective vapor barrier. Different materials have unique strengths and weaknesses and selecting the “right” fabric is really about choosing which compromises to make. Manufacturers make what will sell and build a good reputation. for me, cutting my tent weight down to 2lbs and saving a bunch of space was worth the money. One of the critical aspects of finding the perfect tent lies in the tent fabrics, and the age-old debate of polyester vs nylon tent continues to be a hot topic among outdoor enthusiasts. Feb 25, 2024 · That’s almost one pound (0. Polyester accessory cord from any climbing shop or marine supply will work. I imagine the same thing would happen between high(er) elasticity, lower strength nylon versus low stretch, high strength dyneema. there are diminishing returns as you move past the middle price-points. Therefore a shelter made of Nylon can be lighter than one made of Polyester. As far as I can tell, it should stick to regular nylon just fine. I'm looking at Tyvek 1460C and 40d Nylon/polyester. com 4 days ago · Learn the pros & cons of different tent materials like nylon, polyester, canvas, and Dyneema. For a given weight, nylon or poly provide at least as much floor durability as DCF - I would argue they are better. Nylon is a synthetic material that is lightweight and strong. Before you ask, I am confident that I set it up correctly. A 30D silicone impregnated nylon footprint will be more durable than the same D rating polyester variant. It’s now used It's also important to note that nylon denier does not directly map to wind or water resistance. What's the resulting difference between nylon/nylon paracord vs. Cavas is heavier but darket inside which I like esspecially for the summer. Nylon weaves are water-permeable unless treated or layered with other fabrics (most 1000d backpacks have an additional waterproof liner) Heavy denier nylon is chosen for durability, not weather-resistance. Apr 26, 2024 · Tent Fabric 101: Nylon vs Polyester vs Dyneema/Cuben As in all aspects of tent design, fabric selection is a balancing act. SilNylon can require you to have to re-adjust guylines and tent stakeouts to adjust for the tent for the sag. Noteworthy however is that dyneema has better properties than polyester or nylon when wet - it absorbs less (maybe none) of the water and therefore doesn’t sag. Or the 8lb Coleman 4-man tent with even more room. Key differences among tents is double wall or single wall - double wall helps you avoid brushing yourself or your gear against a wet surface. most do. While polyester doesn't seem to sag, but the trade off is weight and strength. Better UV Resistance The polyester offers better UV resistance than SilNylon, which is a big plus if you plan on leaving your tent out in the sun for extended periods. -my dyneema tent developed pinholes around the apexes and other areas after 2 years of use, weeping water into the tent. I've used Vs with 1. Nylon is stronger, less UV resistant and stretches if whet. If it's hot outside it can be nice to have canvas tent to actually get out of the sun which you won't get with a nylon tent. It's often used in backpacking tents because of its excellent strength-to-weight ratio. When it does so, the stronger, less elastic steel cable would take basically the entire weight. While it not sticking to the tent itself may not have been conclusive (it "can" be used for a temporary emergency on SilNylon, not necessarily a permanent repair), it did not stick whatsoever to a test piece of ripstop nylon I had. Amsteel blue (dyneema) seems to be a favorite on the forums (hamockforums. Tent Fabric 101: Nylon vs Polyester vs Dyneema/Cuben Nylon vs Polyester vs Dyneema/Cuben As for tent, I never had any problems with packing up my dyneema tent. 3000mm any difference for those first 7 days of use? I’m taking a look at that article, thanks for sharing! Btw. I have a Big Agnes Copper Spur 2p tent for 2 person hiking because weight is less of an issue if I split stuff with a partner / friend. I have no experience with the XMid variants, but they do seem to have a good reputation. Dyneema is of course VERY waterproof, but it's also quite a bit more expensive. Polyester is for all other purposes or if I’m trying to cut costs. The traditional dogma in the backpacking tent world is that nylon is a superior fabric over polyester because nylon has better abrasion resistance, better tear strength, and I realize the new coated tent floors are probably much better, but I have so much bad experience with coated fabrics it is hard for me to go that route. Backpacking tents are generally made of one of three materials: coated nylon, coated polyester, or Dyneema composite fabric (DCF). No Oct 11, 2023 · Tent Fabric 101: Nylon vs Polyester vs Dyneema/Cuben . People purchasing a premium tent like the X-Mid Pro 2 should have read the specifications and the price is clearly marked. Specifically the nylon VS Dyneema flooring of the Durston xmid pro 2+. it's entirely up to you to decide if a higher quality item is worth it. Quoting Dan Durston, an experienced hiker and tent designer, on the choice between nylon and polyester: This year i taped up one middle puncture spot and reinforced all 4 corners also with tape. 0oz DCF versus 1. Floor holes in tents arent usually anything too concerning. #1: your ground sheet must not stick out from the edge of your tent - if it does, water will flow into your tent floor. Usually around 16-20mm wide, nylon climbing slings are much bulkier (and more durable) than lightweight 6-14mm Dyneema slings. 210T polyester doesn't 'suck' up water and stays exactly the same shape. I had ProTrail Li, and Altaplex but didnt like the way they set up or fuction. Mar 6, 2022 · Nylon or polyester have some give to them, so there isn’t as much strain on zippers and therefore sliders don’t wear out as quickly. Also it stays lighter when you pack the tent wet as it doesn't absorb water. Polyester Tents. Conversely, nylon is generally stronger than polyester, but less UV resistant. I'm looking for feedback, experience, or knowledge on the floor fabrics of tents. Over time, both nylon and polyester will lose their silicone, so you just purchase a waterproofing spray and reseal. I personally dont care for nylon in most situations. All of my experiences with Dyneema and mylar have been awesome (sail cloth, rope, bags used on the boat etc. It seems as though the only two material choices are nylon or polyester which both come with their trade off's. Its waterproof and UV-resistant properties seem to give it an edge over materials like nylon and polyester, which often struggle with sagging and tear resistance. #2: "footprints" as they are called normally are designed to act as a substitute inner tent for camping in "fastpack" mode. 2oz (30D) nylon as we have here, where the nylon is about 0. Longevity And Wear Polyester and nylon are two common materials used in tent manufacturing, and each has its unique characteristics when it comes to longevity and wear. It does not necessarily mean that nylon is better, but there are many variations from which to choose nowadays. I think it squeezes out more air, and you don't have the fold taking up room. Firstly Dyneema is much lighter when compared to nylon for tents of similar strength. I need a tent that is actually waterproof and can withstand heavy downpours. Do you want it to be light, strong, or inexpensive? The sag of silnylon is a notable con but how much of a problem this is depends on the material (some nylon expands more than other nylon when wet), the tent design (larger panels show this more) and how easily you can adjust the tension. Doesn’t need to be a backpacking tent so it can be heavy if need be 2-4 person tent Tub bottom tent is preferred obviously. Awesome application for it. this EL Wood paracord)? (First of all, is it the outside (mantle?) that is of the different fiber?) Is there much difference in friction? strength? UV resistance? something else? Thanks. For car camping, you'll want privacy. 38 (the larger the number, the heavier per given volume of material). Jan 10, 2020 · Favorite Poly/Nylon Combo Tent (1 to 3 person) MSR Elixir – Although most tents these days are made from nylon, there are a few that use a combination of the two fabrics. While silpoly, a nylon or polyester blend, offers good tear strength and guarantees tents can withstand various outdoor conditions, it doesn’t match the exceptional tear resistance Dyneema Every tent I have tried eventually leaks through the fly so I don’t know what to do. The price is much more expensive and as a general rule DCF also has a reduced useful life but this primarily matters only for a heavy use situation like long thru-hikes. 3mm. Nylon is lighter than polyester but can sag when wet in heavy rainstorms. xwf hsv qfekw sabq vvkmce nhkfjv mbmn ofvq gukc dwtfdkv